A Thousand Ideas. Now What?

Kaizen Snapshot

Setting: Armstrong's global manufacturing planning sessions, bringing together representatives from manufacturing plants around the world.

Challenge: Transform hundreds of improvement ideas into practical initiatives that could actually be implemented.

Stakes: Without clear priorities, defined opportunities, and accountability, valuable ideas could disappear once everyone returned to their plants.

Approach: Shift from generating as many ideas as possible to prioritizing the most promising opportunities and developing detailed concept sheets.

Outcome: Planning sessions evolved to produce approximately 40–60 actionable improvement concepts, with supporting information to help move them toward implementation.

Key Lesson: The value of a planning session isn't measured by how many ideas it generates. It's measured by what happens to those ideas afterward.

A Thousand Ideas!

For many years at Armstrong, I was involved in facilitating global manufacturing planning sessions.

These sessions brought together representatives from our manufacturing plants around the world to identify opportunities to improve safety, quality, delivery, customer service, and cost.

Early in my involvement, I served as a co-facilitator. Eventually, I became the lead facilitator and helped shape how the sessions were conducted.

The participants were knowledgeable, experienced, and enthusiastic about finding ways to improve our business.

And they had plenty of ideas!

During one particularly memorable session, we generated more than 1,000 improvement ideas.

Think about that for a moment. A thousand ideas!

There were Post-it notes everywhere. The walls were covered with suggestions, opportunities, and possibilities. From a brainstorming perspective, it was an impressive accomplishment.

We had brought together talented people from around the world and encouraged them to think creatively about improving our operations.

I remember feeling pretty good about what we'd accomplished. Unfortunately, our sponsors didn't share quite the same enthusiasm.

A Thousand Ideas. Now What?

At the end of the session, we proudly presented our results to the sponsors. More than a thousand improvement ideas!

The team had worked hard, and everyone was understandably pleased with what we'd accomplished.

Our sponsors were gracious. They thanked the participants and recognized their efforts.

But once the presentation was over and the team had left, the facilitators received a very different message.

Our sponsors were disappointed.

They hadn't wanted to discourage the participants, who had invested considerable time and energy in the exercise. So they saved their criticism for those of us responsible for facilitating the session.

And we heard about it!

The problem wasn't that the ideas were bad. Many were probably quite good. The problem was that we hadn't done enough to make them actionable.

We had generated an enormous collection of possibilities, but very little information about which opportunities mattered most, what they would require, or how someone might implement them.

When the participants returned to their plants, what were they supposed to do with a thousand Post-it notes?

Who would decide which ideas deserved attention? Who would investigate them? And who would make sure anything actually happened?

We had done a wonderful job of generating ideas.

But we hadn't created a particularly effective process for turning those ideas into results.

It was a difficult message to hear, especially after what we thought had been such a successful session.

But our sponsors were right.

And their feedback fundamentally changed how we approached these planning sessions.

Fewer Ideas. Better Opportunities.

Rather than abandoning brainstorming, we changed what happened afterward.

We still encouraged participants to think broadly and identify opportunities.

But instead of celebrating the total number of ideas, we began prioritizing them.

Which opportunities offered the greatest potential benefit?

Which could be applied across multiple manufacturing plants?

Which deserved further investigation?

Once we identified the most promising opportunities, teams worked together to develop detailed concept sheets.

Each concept sheet described the proposed improvement, its potential business benefits, expected impact, resources that might be required, and people who could help move it forward.

The objective was straightforward.

Someone should be able to pick up a concept sheet months later and understand the opportunity well enough to begin taking action.

Instead of leaving with a thousand loosely defined ideas, we began producing approximately 40–60 well-developed improvement concepts.

That was a much more valuable outcome.

Getting the Right People Involved

Another important lesson was that identifying an opportunity wasn't always enough.

Sometimes we needed the right people in the room to make progress possible.

For example, some of our manufacturing teams identified opportunities to substitute lower-cost raw materials without compromising product performance.

On paper, the potential savings looked attractive.

But changing raw materials often required agreement from people beyond the manufacturing plants.

By involving corporate stakeholders in the planning process, we could discuss concerns, challenge assumptions, and build alignment around promising opportunities.

That helped create a path toward implementation rather than leaving the ideas stranded on a wall.

It reinforced something I've seen repeatedly throughout my career.

The people needed to implement an improvement aren't always the same people who first identify it.

What Happens After Everyone Goes Home?

We also recognized that even the best concept sheets wouldn't guarantee results. Someone needed to follow up.

Over time, Armstrong developed a visual management board and a monthly corporate review process to track progress on the improvement opportunities.

That created greater visibility into which initiatives were advancing and which needed attention.

I wasn't involved in every implementation, and I can't speak to how the process evolved after I left Armstrong.

But I saw how much more useful our planning sessions became when we focused on developing opportunities that people could actually pursue.

The objective was no longer simply to have a productive meeting. It was to create a foundation for meaningful improvements.

A Lesson I've Carried Into My Kaizen Work

Today, I apply the same thinking when facilitating Value Stream Mapping events and strategic improvement planning sessions for my clients.

We still brainstorm. We still encourage creativity. And we still want people to challenge the way things have always been done.

But we don't stop with a wall full of Post-it notes.

We prioritize opportunities, develop detailed concept sheets, identify ownership, and build improvement roadmaps that can guide an organization over the next one to three years.

Depending on the scope of the event, we might develop 15–20 or more actionable concepts.

The number isn't the goal. The goal is to give leaders and improvement teams enough information to make informed decisions and take the next steps.

Because a great idea that nobody acts upon doesn't improve anything.

The Takeaway

Looking back, I'm glad we generated those thousand ideas. It was an important learning experience.

But I'm even more grateful that our sponsors challenged us to do better.

They helped me understand that the success of a planning session shouldn't be measured by the number of ideas covering the walls.

It should be measured by the quality of the opportunities developed and, ultimately, the improvements that follow.

A thousand ideas might make for an impressive photograph.

A handful of implemented improvements can make a much bigger difference to the business.

And that's what continuous improvement is really about.

Ready to turn improvement opportunities into an actionable roadmap?

Previous
Previous

From 46 Minutes to 15: A Huddle Transformation

Next
Next

The Pressure You Couldn’t See