The Pressure You Couldn’t See

Leadership Snapshot

Setting: Armstrong's vinyl flooring manufacturing plant in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

Challenge: Build a productive working relationship with a local union president who seemed determined to keep management at a distance.

Stakes: A difficult labor-management relationship made communication, cooperation, and improvement efforts more challenging.

Turning Point: An unexpected interaction between the local union president and an international union leader revealed pressures I hadn't previously considered.

Outcome: Our relationship didn't significantly improve, but my understanding of the situation changed.

Key Lesson: Before judging someone's behavior, consider the pressures and expectations that may be influencing their actions.

You Tell That Guy...

Earlier in my career at Armstrong, I served as a business unit manager at our vinyl flooring manufacturing plant in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

The plant had a long history of union representation and its share of challenges between management and the union.

I knew building productive relationships would be important to my success. Unfortunately, that wasn't going to be easy.

I remember one of my first interactions with the local union president.

During a meeting, a discussion arose about something I wanted to address. Rather than speaking directly to me, the union president turned to one of my colleagues.

“You tell that guy he's not going to change this or that!”

I was standing right there! He could have looked me in the eye and told me himself. But apparently, he preferred to deliver his message through someone else.

It was an awkward introduction. And it certainly didn't suggest we were going to become close friends.

A Difficult Relationship

Over time, I found the union president difficult to engage.

I understood that we represented different interests and that disagreements were inevitable. That wasn't the issue.

I'd worked with plenty of employees and union representatives who disagreed with management decisions but were still willing to have constructive conversations.

This felt different. There seemed to be a deliberate distance between us, and I couldn't understand why he was so unwilling to establish even a basic working relationship.

Then something happened that gave me an entirely different perspective.

An Unexpected Factory Tour

One day, the plant's senior managers were away attending a conference.

That left the four business unit managers responsible for hosting an important visitor.

The international president of the union was coming to tour our facility. Naturally, the local union president accompanied him.

Our responsibility was to show him around the plant, explain our operations, and answer questions.

I expected the usual discussions about manufacturing processes, working conditions, and business challenges.

What I didn't expect was the way the international president treated our local union president.

During the tour, he openly criticized him for allowing management to run all over him. And he wasn't particularly diplomatic about it!

He used some very strong language, including plenty of profanity, to express his displeasure. All of this happened right in front of us. But what struck me most wasn't the language.

It was the local union president's reaction.

The same man who had been so confrontational toward me now appeared intimidated by his own international president.

It was uncomfortable to witness. But it also made me wonder whether I was seeing something that might explain our difficult relationship.

Suddenly, Things Looked Different

Until that moment, I'd viewed our relationship primarily from my own perspective.

I wanted to establish a productive working relationship. He seemed unwilling. I couldn't understand why.

But watching the international president berate him made me consider something I hadn't previously appreciated.

What if the local president was under tremendous pressure to demonstrate that he was standing up to management?

Perhaps he believed maintaining a confrontational relationship was necessary to satisfy his union leadership.

Perhaps he worried that cooperating with management would make him appear weak.

Or perhaps there were other pressures I knew nothing about. I didn't know. And I still don't.

But for the first time, I considered that his behavior toward me might not have been entirely about me.

He may have been responding to pressures I couldn't see.

That was an important realization.

Understanding Doesn't Mean Agreeing

I wish I could tell you that this experience transformed our relationship. It didn't.

The local union president continued to keep his distance, and our interactions remained challenging.

But something had changed. My perspective.

I still believed we should communicate respectfully and work together when our interests aligned.

And I still disagreed with some of his behavior.

But I became more aware that people operate within relationships, expectations, and pressures that aren't always visible to us.

Understanding that possibility didn't excuse his behavior. It simply helped me see it differently.

The Leadership Lesson

I've carried that experience with me throughout my career.

Whether I'm working with manufacturing leaders, frontline employees, supervisors, or improvement teams, I try to remember that people don't operate in isolation.

A supervisor who resists change may be worried about meeting production targets.

An employee reluctant to participate may have had a bad experience with an earlier improvement initiative.

A manager unwilling to make a decision may be responding to expectations from someone higher in the organization.

We don't always know what pressures people are facing.

And sometimes our assumptions about their motivations are completely wrong.

That doesn't mean ignoring difficult behavior or avoiding accountability.

But it does mean being careful about drawing conclusions before understanding the situation.

The Takeaway

That factory tour didn't improve my relationship with the local union president. But it improved something else.

My ability to recognize that the behavior I see may be influenced by circumstances I don't understand.

It's a lesson that has served me well as a leader and Kaizen facilitator.

Because successful improvement depends on understanding people, not just processes.

And sometimes the most important thing to understand is something you can't immediately see.

Before you judge someone's behavior, ask yourself what pressures might be influencing it.

You may discover there's more to the story than you realized.

Want to build stronger teams and create lasting improvements?

Previous
Previous

A Thousand Ideas. Now What?

Next
Next

Hidden Capacity Was Sitting Above Their Heads