Who says you can’t speed up innovation?

After a three-year stint as Operations Manager in a plant in Oregon, I was offered the opportunity to return to the Innovation Group for Armstrong World Industries, a ceiling tile manufacturer.  I was to support a team of scientists and technicians, and help them improve their processes and speed up the time to launch new product ideas.

In my first few weeks, I spent time observing the processes the team used to come up with new ideas and bring them to fruition.  Each scientist, with the help of assigned technicians, would develop their own approved idea, using whatever development technique they chose to use.  Every so often, their manager would meet with them to review status and see if there was any help needed to drive progress.  More often than not, the scientist would not ask for any additional help.  Even less likely was the chance the scientist would go to their manager when they were stuck and needed help.  Things took a long time to complete. 

I also took a look at the innovation spaces and testing centers that supported the Innovation Team.  Disorganized and disconnected, these spaces became available on a first come, first served basis.  Scientists often had to wait for testing assistance, as there was no clear way to prioritize or schedule work in the spaces. 

Pilot Plants

I knew I could bring some value to this group, as long as I had someone to sponsor me.  I was new to this area and had to build credibility.  Luckily, I found a manager who was frustrated with the amount of time things took and was open to trying something new.

The first thing we decided to do was pick a target area in the testing spaces (our Pilot Plant) to organize, with the idea of improving productivity and responsiveness for testing.  We picked a small team and used a 5S (Sort, Set in Order, Shine, Standardize, Sustain) event to improve the area and named an Area Owner.  The owner would reserve the area for the scientists and technicians and ensure work was prioritized properly.  This first owner had to have strong leadership backing and the internal fortitude to stand behind her choices.  Luckily, our first owner had both.

This first 5S effort brought immediate and visible positive results to the Pilot Plant.  Over the next few months (and years), more and more areas became organized using 5S and strong leadership support.  Work flowed through the Pilot Plant in a much quicker way.  Strong Area Owners ensured the highest priority work would be done before lesser value work.  If anyone tried to break the rules, the owners knew they had support for their efforts to control the work flow.

Now that we had simplified and streamlined the testing work, we needed to come up with a way to make the development work more visible.  As I stated earlier, scientists liked to do their own thing and then present their inventions and discoveries in their own time.  Because of that, there was no clear way to assess progress and provide help or support during the process.

With the support of the manager, we approached the Innovation Director with this idea:  Have a weekly meeting of all scientists and technicians to give them the opportunity to discuss their progress and talk about next steps and any help they might need.  The Director was intrigued, but was unsure how the group would react to “structure”.  He told us, “You can’t schedule invention.”  My reply was, “Maybe you can’t, but you can schedule the steps on the way to invention.”  If nothing else, the scientists would have an opportunity to share their discoveries with the group.  He thought it was worth a try and decided to start the following week.

Accelerating Innovation

The first weekly Innovation Group Huddles were unstructured on purpose.  The Innovation Director asked each scientist to talk about what they were working on.  Some of the scientists were willing to do so and would take the time to describe the intimate details of their work.  Others had little to say, and even with prodding didn’t seem willing to share.  Although it was frustrating at the beginning, we realized this was the first time the team had the opportunity to discuss their efforts in this way, and agreed to keep the process going for a while to see what might happen.

About three months after starting the Innovation Huddle, a scientist was talking about his work and admitted he was a bit stuck on how to test one of his ideas.  For the first time, another scientist spoke up and said, “I worked on something similar three years ago and I would be happy to share my data and results with you, if you think that would help.”  All of the sudden, the entire group opened up and realized why they were there.  They could share and learn from each other.  Scientists love to share and learn, and now they knew this was their forum to do so.

Over the years, the Innovation Group Huddle became more visible, more engaging, and focused on helping each scientist and technician in their efforts.  After four years, the time to market, from initial idea to launch was reduced from eighteen to ten months.  The portfolio of new products developed by the Innovation team more than doubled from $150 million to $380 million.